Our company name is also our method. On every roof we shingle, the field shingles go on with a hammer, one nail at a time, and no nail gun touches them. People sometimes ask whether that is just a slogan. It isn’t. It is one of the biggest factors in whether a shingle roof stays put when a storm rolls through Montgomery County, and this post explains why we have never given it up.
What a nail really does on a shingle roof
An asphalt shingle is held down two ways. The sealant strip on each shingle softens in the sun and glues it to the course below. Until that bond forms, and anywhere it fails later, the nails are the only thing keeping the shingle on the deck.
Most manufacturers print a nailing zone on their shingles, usually a narrow band across the middle, and every one of them spells it out in the installation instructions. On a laminated (architectural) shingle, that band sits where the two layers of the shingle overlap, so a nail placed there pins both layers and also catches the top edge of the shingle underneath. A nail just outside the band may hold only one layer, or it may end up exposed under the next course where water can find it.
Four nailing mistakes we find on roofs we repair
When we pull shingles on a leak call or after a wind event, the same problems show up over and over:
- Overdriven nails. The head is sunk into or through the shingle mat. In a hard gust the shingle can tear right around the nail, because there is nothing left for the head to grip.
- Underdriven nails. The head stands above the surface. It props up the shingle above it so the sealant strip can’t make full contact, and over time the head can rub a hole through that shingle.
- Crooked nails. A nail driven at an angle cuts the mat on one side of the head and leaves the other side loose. It looks fastened and holds far less.
- High or low nails. Outside the nailing zone, a nail misses the second layer or the shingle below, or shows in the gap of the next course.
None of these can be seen from the ground. A roof can look perfect for years and then lose a section in its first serious wind.
Why a nail gun makes those mistakes easy
To be fair to nail guns, a well-adjusted gun in careful hands can put a nail in the right spot. The trouble is everything around the gun. Air pressure drifts as the compressor cycles and the hose run gets longer. A deck baking in the afternoon sun takes a nail differently than the same deck early in the morning. Plywood and OSB don’t drive alike, and an older deck is softer in some places than others. The gun hits every nail with the same force no matter what is under it, and it fires as fast as the roofer can move. When a crew is racing to finish, the pace wins.
A hammer works the other way. The roofer sees each nail go in, sets it straight, stops when the head is snug against the shingle, and adjusts on the next one. If the wood under a nail is soft or rotted, you feel it through the handle, and we deal with that piece of decking before it gets covered up.
What it means when the wind blows
Wind damage usually starts small. One shingle that wasn’t held well lifts, and that exposes the edge of its neighbor. Hand-set nails, flush and straight inside the nailing zone, give each shingle the hold its maker designed it to have. That matters here, where spring storms, tropical systems and strong summer gusts are part of life, and where a roof put on in cooler weather may wait a while before the sun seals every strip.
We follow each manufacturer’s nailing instructions, including the extra nails its high-wind pattern calls for when a job needs it.
What it means for your manufacturer warranty
Shingle warranties are written around the manufacturer’s installation instructions, and nailing is a big part of those instructions. If shingles blow off and an inspection turns up nails that are high, crooked or overdriven, the manufacturer can point at the installation instead of the product. Getting the nailing right is one of the simplest ways to keep that coverage worth something. As a CertainTeed ShingleMaster™ credentialed contractor, we have trained on how that manufacturer wants its shingles put down, and we hold every brand we install to its own published instructions. Our own workmanship warranty is spelled out in writing on your estimate.
Andy is on every job
Hand-nailing only works if someone is paying attention to it. Andy Hughes owns Handnail Roofing and supervises every job himself. He is there checking the deck and the nailing while the roof goes up, instead of finding out about a problem after the crew has packed up. Handnail Roofing is owner-run and local, so the person who answers for your roof is the same person watching it go on. You can read more about how we run the company on our about page.
Hand-nailing is slower, and we build our schedule around that instead of cutting corners to save time. Whether we are tearing off an old roof for a roof replacement or shingling a fresh deck for a roof installation, every field shingle gets nailed the same way.
Questions to ask any roofer
Whoever you hire, these are fair things to ask before you sign:
- Will the field shingles be nailed by hand or with a gun? If a gun, who checks the pressure, and how often?
- How many nails go in each shingle, and will you use the manufacturer’s high-wind pattern?
- Who is on the roof checking nail placement while the work is going on?
- What happens if you find soft or damaged decking once the old roof is off?
- What does your workmanship warranty cover, and is it in writing?
Want us to take a look?
If you are wondering how your roof was nailed, or you are planning a new one, we will come out for a free roof inspection and tell you plainly what we see. Call or text Andy at (281) 819-6054.
